NHS QUESTIONS

Which A&E Indicators Belong on an NHS Performance Dashboard?

Start with the number of A&E visits, how long they lasted and how they ended. Read the figures together to see whether longer waits coincided with a busier department or a change in how many visits ended in admission.

Show the time from arrival and the time after a decision to admit separately. The two measures answer different questions, even when both are labelled as 12-hour waits.

  
Department activity

Start with attendances

An attendance is a visit. If someone comes to A&E twice in the period you’re reporting on, they can account for two attendances. For a daily huddle, arrivals by hour help the team see when pressure built. For a monthly review, start with the total and show which sites and department types it covers.

Imagine an analyst putting together a review of one major emergency department, known as Type 1, for a single reporting period. Their example uses 200 eligible, unplanned attendances with an end recorded. They keep that scope fixed as they work through the timings and outcomes.

Say which departments are included

A trust-wide total can include a major emergency department and an urgent treatment centre. Label the department types so the reader knows what sits behind the number.

  
Time spent in A&E

Keep the two waiting-time clocks separate

On an A&E performance dashboard, for the four-hour measure, count the eligible attendances that ended in admission, transfer or discharge within four hours of arrival. In the example, 150 of 200 visits ended within four hours, giving 75%. Show the count alongside the percentage.

For very long visits, show time from arrival to departure as its own measure. In the example, 12 of 200 attendances lasted more than 12 hours from arrival, or 6%.

Take one of those visits. The person arrives at 8am. At 5.30pm, the team records the decision to admit them. The treatment they needed in A&E before admission is already complete. The patient leaves A&E and is admitted at 8.30pm. That’s 12 hours and 30 minutes from arrival and three hours waiting for admission.

For the NHS admission-wait measure, the clock starts when the decision to admit is recorded and any treatment that must happen in A&E before admission is complete. If those events happen at different times, use the later one. Stop the clock at the recorded time of admission.

Put the start point in the label

“Over 12 hours from arrival” and “over 12 hours after a decision to admit” can sit side by side. Give each its own label so readers can tell what the figure measures.

  
Visit outcomes

Put the outcome next to the wait

Break down attendances by how the visit ended. Of the 200 visits in the example, 40 ended in admission, 146 in discharge and 10 in transfer. The remaining four had other recorded outcomes. That gives the team context for the waiting times and a starting point for looking more closely.

Keep other outcomes visible and flag missing ones if they appear in your data. If you show waiting times by outcome, include the number of attendances in each group. A large percentage can be made up of only a handful of visits.

Check what “admissions” means

Label the dashboard count “A&E attendances resulting in admission” if that’s what it measures. A wider emergency admissions total can include people admitted by other routes.

  
Compare like with like

Check the source before comparing figures

The monthly A&E Attendances and Emergency Admissions situation report (SitRep) provides published activity and four-hour figures, as well as waits after a decision to admit. The Emergency Care Data Set (ECDS) supplementary analysis specification explains how measures such as time in department from arrival are built from attendance records. It includes versions of the over-12-hours measure with different department coverage.

Before comparing two figures, check the reporting period, provider or site, department types, which attendances qualify and how the clock is defined. Display the source and scope alongside each figure so the next reader can make the same checks.

What to check before comparing A&E figures
  • Do the figures cover the same sites, department types and dates?
  • Which attendances are counted, and which are excluded?
  • When does each clock start and stop?
  • Are both figures drawn from the same release or revision?

Keep local and published figures labelled

A huddle may need today’s arrivals and current waits. A board report may use the latest published month. Label the time period and source so the two views can serve their own readers.

  
Your next step

Build one view for your next review

Start with one department and one reporting period. Put the attendance total, four-hour performance, long waits from arrival and visit outcomes together. Pick one figure a colleague is likely to ask about and make sure they can see exactly what you counted.

If you’re evaluating IntelliFront BI, use the guide to plan how the dashboard will show your counts and definitions. The NHS hospital pharmacy dashboards give an example of how another NHS team arranges operational views around the questions staff ask.

Download the IntelliFront BI Internal Evaluation Guide

Contributors:

Christian Ofori-Boateng

Christian Ofori-Boateng

CEO, ChristianSteven Software